THE GOOD: They transfer fairly smoothly. The black and the brown shades are good essentials and the purple is available if you want the pop of colour.
THE BAD: The 'shimmer' aspect of this product lacked greatly as there was hardly any shimmer to be seen at all! Really, it just did not even show to exist - you can see from the swatches. I was really disappointed in the black liner mainly because I already own black liners and this one is basically a black eyeliner where you might spot a speck of purple sparkle somewhere once in a while ... if you are lucky.
BASICALLY...: I recommend this to someone who is just starting with makeup and does not own any eyeliners already as this is relatively of good quality for just coloured eyeliners. This is a good "beginners" item as it comes with three eyeliners that complement your eye colour. It will cover the basics!